Option FanaticOptions, stock, futures, and system trading, backtesting, money management, and much more!

Why Earnings Just Don’t Make Sense (Part 1)

Earnings just don’t make sense to me with regard to stock price movement.

While I have seen many anecdotal instances to support this hypothesis, I will use one example to keep this blog series short: Google 2013 Q4 results, which were reported on January 31, 2014. I will present three reports on the earnings announcement.

In no particular order, here is Report #1 from Zacks:

> Google Misses, Shares Up Regardless
>
> Google Inc (GOOG) reported fourth-quarter earnings of $9.93,
> missing the Zacks Consensus Estimate by 41 cents, or 4.1%…
> shares jumped 4.1% after-hours, after rallying 2.6% during
> the day. Google’s gross revenue came in at $16.86 billion…

Here is Report #2 from The Motley Fool:

> Google and Amazon Earnings
>
> Google earnings top expectations. Google this: Shares of
> the search engine that you probably used two minutes ago
> jumped more than 4% in after-hours trading Thursday, after
> Google (NASDAQ: GOOG ) reported a projection-beating
> $16.9 billion in revenues last quarter.
>
> The takeaway is that Google’s earnings figures were
> pretty hot…

Here is Report #3 from The Verge:

> Google Q4 2013: strong revenue growth driven by Play
> Store and hardware sales
>
> The search giant missed earnings expectations by a
> wide margin but wasn’t punished by traders.
>
> It seems like Google can do no wrong with the markets
> these days. The consensus estimate on Wall Street was
> that Google would deliver $16.75 billion in revenue
> and earnings of $12.26 a share. It hit the top of that
> line, with $16.86 billion in revenue, but missed on
> the bottom with earnings of $12.01 a share. Still,
> the stock was up slightly in after-hours trading.
> Google made $14.4 billion in revenue and earned
> $8.62 a share for this same period a year ago. Last
> quarter Google brought in $14.8 billion and earned
> $10.47 a share.

I will compare and contrast Report #1, Report #2, and Report #3 in the next post.